This upcoming crossover release for Magic: The Gathering centered on Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles has not yet been released, but it's already creating tremendous buzz. Packed with gorgeous illustrations featuring myriad versions of the turtles, the cards nod to sources ranging from the original comics to beloved animated series, movies, and even niche action figures.
For those who are a fanatic of the half-shell heroes who additionally enjoys Magic: The Gathering, this is the time you've been waiting for. Then there are fans like me. I'm a die-hard TMNT fanatic captivated since childhood, who has zero knowledge about the first thing about Magic. I've never played a hand. Still, I'm incredibly excited about this crossover. My excitement stems from a deep love for the franchise and the amazing history represented on these cards. I adore them so much that I've picked out the 10 best cards in the entire set, judged solely on their "cool factor" of TMNT canon. Is any of this playable in an actual game? My editor, and they're in the dark. A slight letdown is the glaring omission of any nod to the infamous Coming Out of Their Shells album and tour, which feels like a missed opportunity.
10. A Classic Comic Moment
This artwork is taken directly from the 11th issue of the original comic series, showcasing co-creator Kevin Eastman's initial design of April O'Neil. This version is an frequently referenced piece of character history, showcasing her later transformation into a brunette reporter in a distinctive outfit from the cartoon.
9. A Nod to Video Game History
Similar to a number of other cards, Shellshock is a direct homage to classic TMNT arcade titles. In the first arcade game, the Turtles could be zapped by a robot named Roadkill Rodney, resulting in a comical visual gag that is exactly recreated here. This moment grew into a signature bit in subsequent games and was even immortalized as an collectible toy in 2020.
8. Deep-Cut Villainy
We must pause to acknowledge that a card was made based on Tempestra, a largely obscure single-episode antagonist from a 1990 installment of the animated series. In the somewhat ridiculous episode, Leonardo becomes obsessed with a video game featuring this digital foe, who is brought to life during an electrical storm. Although the episode may not be remembered as a high point, the fact that the designers went this deep into the archives of TMNT antagonists is highly respectable.
7. Fast Forward
This set includes multiple homages to the excellent 1991 arcade classic Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Turtles in Time. This card is notable because the flavor text at the bottom explicitly references the "Neon Night Riders" level, a memorable stage where the perspective shifts to a third-person angle for a hoverboard sequence before a boss battle against Krang.
6. Alien Greasers
For anyone who grew up watching the original TMNT cartoon, the Neutrinos were undoubtedly the height of cool. These three greaser-inspired aliens, introduced in the episode "Hot Rodding Teenagers," spoke in high-pitched squeaks, piloted a cool vehicle, and always brought chaos. Their inclusion perfectly captures the spirit of these chaotic characters.
5. Leonardo, Sewer Samurai Art Card
As a longtime TMNT fan, it's heartwarming to see a card based on a particular toy, instead of a cartoon or movie. The franchise's heyday in the late 20th century was defined by unique action figures. This art card showcases a detailed drawing of Leonardo as he appeared in the 1990 "Sewer Samurai" action figure, a design that wasn't featured in any media but is now forever immortalized here. Those interested, this special art card has standard foil versions to find as well.
4. A Goofy Movie Moment
Although Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles II: The Secret of the Ooze was a sillier sequel, it introduced the monsters Tokka and Rahzar. Tainted Treats depicts the climax where the turtles and Professor Jordan Perry develop an "ooze retardant", place it in frozen doughnuts, and use them against the monstrous mutants. It's a quirky piece of film lore captured on cardboard.
3. The Last Ronin's Technique
A few cards reference the powerful 2020 comic Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: The Last Ronin, but this one most powerfully conveys the narrative's emotional weight. The tale follows the sole survivor Turtle fighting in a ravaged New York, wielding all the grief and pain of witnessing his brothers. It's a somber but deeply resonant story that fans had long awaited.
2. The Ultimate Crossover
Turtles Forever is like a love letter for dedicated fans. Although evoking the 2009 crossover movie, it one-ups it by featuring the live-action of Donatello with his animated brothers. The funny scale is charming, and while it would have been the ideal place for a keytar nod to Coming Out of Their Shells, the card stands as a fantastic celebration of the Turtles' varied history.
1. Teleportation Circle
Picking Teleportation Circle as the best was difficult. Its image is taken from the cover of the notorious 1989 NES Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles game, a foundational memory for countless fans. When we got that game, many assumed it was a version of the popular arcade game. How wrong.
The NES game was a notoriously difficult side-scroller that didn't capture the fun of the cartoon. But, it was our only TMNT game at home for a while. Taking Splinter's lessons, I practiced and tried to beat it.
I failed. To this day, I can't defeat it. The dreaded underwater level with the deadly plants was pure torture. Yet, the joy was in the struggle, a sentiment this card beautifully evokes.